THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS
THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS
THE BRAIN IN A VAT
Hilary Putnam, 1981 What if you’re a brain in a jar wired to a computer feeding you this exact page? You can’t prove you aren’t. → So act on what you can test, and enjoy the view either way. LAST THURSDAYISM a philosophy joke What if the universe was created last Thursday, complete with your memories, fossils and old photos? Nothing could disprove it. → Your past is a story either way. Tell a good one.
THE EXPERIENCE MACHINE
Robert Nozick, 1974 A machine can give you any experience you want: fame, love, winning. Forever. Would you plug in? Most people say no. → We want to do things, not just feel them. That’s being human. THE CHINESE ROOM John Searle, 1980 A man who speaks no Chinese follows a rulebook to answer Chinese questions perfectly. Does he understand Chinese? Does the AI you talk to? → Producing the right words isn’t the same as meaning them.
THE SHIP OF THESEUS
Plutarch, ~100 AD Replace every plank of a ship one by one. Is it the same ship? Your cells, beliefs and job all change. Are you the same you? → You get to decide which planks to replace next. PLATO’S CAVE The Republic, ~375 BC Prisoners watch shadows on a wall and think that’s reality. One escapes and sees the sun. When he returns, they want to kill him. → The feed is the wall. This book is the exit. Expect pushback. THE RABBIT HOLE 223 THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS · NO LAB REQUIRED WHAT IF NOTHING IS WHAT IT SEEMS? Six questions philosophers have argued about for centuries. Try one at your next dinner party. 0→YOU×AI
